Okay, I can bet I’m going to get a lot of flack for this post, so before I start, this is only my opinion and is not at all based on actual numbers. The only reason I’m putting a graph here is because I think it’s easier to visually explain. No numbers. Got it? Just opinion. Don’t get all excited here. Okay. Calm yet? Okay, now don’t start reading this post unless you intend to read the whole thing. Ready? Now you may continue reading the post.
The last post I made was describing just a small smattering of some of my personal Firefox woes around the add-ons that I use to personally secure myself from attacks that either I have helped create, or have seen in the wild. Now, truth be told, I use Firefox every day, due to the add-ons that it supports and the ease of testing webapps. And it’s with that that I’m disheartened by my sense of helplessness around updates.
So here’s what I feel is happening over time for security people (not for the regular every day casual web surfer, but indeed, hardcore security folks, like most of the people who read this site). Over time there are upgrades. Those upgrades fix a number holes, and introduce a few others. They also break the add-ons. Those add-ons help fix the broken browser security model. Therefore, for the likes of me and the vulns I actually am affected by, my security is reduced with each new major revision of the browser, making it look something like this:
Sure, the overall security is trending up with time, but there are major gaps in my perceived security while developers catch up to the new codebase. While the numbers and timelines may be way off, the concept (for me at least) is right. I don’t personally see any immediate major benefit from the browser changes - only negative. With time, sure, things get better, but I happen to be in a particularly bad security slump at the moment right there on the right hand side of the graph. The exploit code that I may have been at risk of, for the most part, is neutered by the add-ons, until they stop working. So which is it? Am I trusting the browser to evolve faster than the add-ons or vice versa?
Firefox’s model has always been, “Feel free to contribute, it’s open source!” While this is great in theory, a) My programming skills get me by and not much more - you don’t want my code in your browser holding the Internet together, trust me b) I don’t have access to all the security bugs - most of the worst of which are hidden from view on bugzilla for only a very small select few people to view and c) there are very few people who have the ability to commit code let alone to fix other people’s add-ons.
It’s tempting to get overwhelmed by the helplessness of it all, but then I just remember that none of these plugins fix things like CSRF which helps me ignore that particular issue. So then I just go home and cry myself to sleep. Okay, now rant away, but if you mis-quote me or fail to read everything before commenting, so help me, I’ll make fun of you senselessly.
Tags:
Security,
Security news
Related posts
) and click the bookmarklet. It sends the domain to ha.ckers.org which performs an IP lookup and forwards the browser back to MSN with the IP for that domain. It’s that simple. You’d be amazed how many companies use shared hosting.
